Thursday, February 05, 2004
Debating the debate coach
No set of Standards can be letter-perfect, and signers of this letter reserve the right to comment individually on specific points. Subject to such adjustment, the Standards are in our judgment a reasonable approximation of what K-12 students ought to be learning in these areas, and we recommend their approval by the Legislature.I actually already have sent some of these to the committee.
Meanwhile, here's the teacher's web page. Using the MAPSSS tactic one could say someone who links to Tom Tomorrow is a blatant left-wing ideologue. But rather, I'd ask her what she means by "You don't fatten a pig by weighing it", in relation to the standards (written in August, before they even came out)? And how about this?
My student teacher (who just got her license in January) confirms that the standard distribution requirements are still thereAh yes, Praxis. A test passed in 1985 but only given to teachers first in 2001. Luckily, anyone with a license before 9/1/01 doesn't have to pass it, since new teachers in 2001-02 answered only 68% of the geography questions correctly nationwide. Later Teacher says
1 geography (Carleton essentially allowed their students ... to skip this requirement for some reason)
1 economics
1 sociology (you'll get this in your licensure classes anyways)
1 psychology (you'll get this in your licensure classes anyways)
1 US history
1 world history
1 political science/government
... at Carleton at least 2 or 3 of the classes need to be upper-level, not intro. I don't remember that part at Macalester. Nobody seemed to care at all about the actual topics studied.
Also there is now this silly praxis content-area test.
Quite honestly, I don't really see why a person needs a major in chemistry in order to teach high school chemistry, or why a person teaching 8th grade math needs to have a math major. I think there's more potential damage when the teacher doesn't have a good set of teaching skills than when she/he doesn't fully grasp college-level subject matter.
*--Because we're not yet drug y podruga.